Charlie Self, hospitality, church, catholicity, pastors, community, compromise, compassion, gospel, welcome, christianity

The rest is in the pages of Common Good.


Already a subscriber? Sign in.

What Does Compassion Without Compromise Look Like?

The 2 commitments required for catholicity in the work of the gospel.

How do we love everyone and maintain the holy standards of Jesus for believers in the church? 

We say, “Welcome!” and sincerely desire that everyone feel the warmth of Christ’s love through us. At the same time, when we call people to believe the gospel and follow Christ wholeheartedly, there are moral absolutes that many unbelievers think make us intolerant. 

Clarity of concepts and moral alignment are vital in a world where many people see meaning as malleable and morality as relative. We live in a pluralistic world filled with competing worldviews, and many view Christianity with hostility or indifference. Recognizing the pluralistic reality all around us is not the same as a philosophy of pluralism that aims at homogenizing religious ideals or positing that any and all faiths lead to God.

As apprentices of Jesus committed to the supremacy of the gospel of Jesus Christ and the necessity of calling all people to repentance from sin and faith in the death and resurrection of Jesus, it is essential that we define and integrate two key concepts so that we are loyal to the timeless faith once entrusted to the saints (I Cor 15:1-6; Jude 3) and timely in our presentation of truth with love, knowing that it is God’s will that the church reflect God’s glory, with women and men from all backgrounds, classes, cultures, and ethnicities (Gal 3:28-4:7; Eph 2:11-21, 3:3-10; Rev 7:9).

Hospitality to All

The first concept is the biblical call to hospitality. We welcome all seekers from any and every background to experience the love of Christ in community and discover, in the words of Saint Augustine, “You have made us for Yourself, and our heart is restless until it rests in You.” Both Old and New Testaments call upon God’s people to love and serve the “outsiders” in their midst. Moses’ marriage, the stories of Naaman the Syrian healed by the prophet Elijah, Ruth the Moabite convert, and the Book of Jonah are provocative reminders to God’s elect that they are chosen as a light to all nations (Isa 42-43, 49, 60-61). F. F. Bruce said it well a generation ago: God did not choose Israel to be an exclusive community, but that through them all nations would be blessed. 

The journeys of Jesus and the apostles in Luke through Acts reinforce this embrace of all people. Luke 4, 7, and 19 find Jesus commending the faith of outsiders, welcoming the outcast, and challenging his fellow Jews to learn from them. The progress of mission in Acts moves from a Jewish prayer meeting to a universal faith. 

For almost 2,000 years the church has failed deeply, and at times succeeded miraculously, in experiencing the new sociology, where former enemies are friends and diverse classes and cultures find community in the power of the Holy Spirit. 

As believers, we affirm the wonder of the beautiful community the Holy Spirit creates when all are welcome and we dedicate ourselves to removing all human barriers to inclusion and empowerment (Eph 2:11-21, 3:3-10). Even more, we aim that diversity is not symbolic but substantive, not window dressing to assuage majority guilt but immersed in the community as faith and baptism unite believers. Practically, this means we welcome spiritual seekers and are unafraid to answer tough questions. We see every person we encounter as both beautiful and broken — a divine image-bearer and in need of the saving grace of Christ. We aspire to see all gospel churches filled with all kinds of people experiencing reconciliation, redemption, restoration, and community through the gospel (2 Cor 5:11-6:2). 

Death to Self

The second concept is a companion to the first: Following Jesus requires the believer to die to their sovereignty — letting go of self-will as well as sinful actions and attitudes — and live under God’s loving and holy rule as a new creation in Christ, member of the body of Christ, and one liberated from darkness and called into the light of faith and truth (2 Cor 5:17; Col 1:15-23; Eph 4:1-12, 22-24). Put simply, being a Christ-follower includes obedience to God’s Word and a love for the ways of God — principles and practices vastly different from those of the unbelieving world.

We confess that too often the church has imposed religious traditions that are not rooted in the grace and truth of Scripture. With humility, we must repent of being more religious than Jesus or making excuses for our proclivities toward idolatry, immorality, and injustice (Isa 44; Amos 2, 4; 1 John 5). Yet with love and grace, the church does promote the clear moral absolutes of Scripture. 

The Bible is replete with the heroes of faith failing miserably. This does not, however, change the divine standard or allow for excuses. When we fail, we are called to repent and allow the community to restore us (Gal 6). If someone confesses Christ as Lord, they are incorporated into the body of Christ and called to accountability in the local church (1 Cor). Old beliefs, habits, attitudes, and actions now yield to King Jesus, who calls us to a much better way — the way of humility and joy (Mark 10:45). 

Women and men who come to our churches carry burdens and scars, histories of hurt, the strongholds of false ideologies and religions, as well as amazing potential as those to whom Christ offers forgiveness and wholeness. We welcome all, and we call all to repentance and renewal, unselfish love and holiness, born of gratitude for God’s grace (Deut 10:12-13; Eph 4:1-6). 

What changes when Jesus is Lord?

  • Gospel grace means sexual ethics are now celibacy for singles and fidelity in biblical marriages. It means the community will walk with people from all arenas of gender identity as they learn conformity to Christ and not to cultural norms.
  • Business ethics change completely as all work is for God’s glory and the good of others.
  • Relationships of all kinds change for the better as love and wisdom guide deeds and words instead of selfish advancement.
  • Political service is now for the common good, not personal power.
  • The creative arts are unleashed, exposing our deep wounds and offering hope and healing.

Compassion without compromise is the order of the day, in a world where inversion and perversion are celebrated (Rom 1:18-32). As is patient pilgrimage. The early church faced similar challenges and rose to the occasion well. The Acts 15 council united Jew and Gentile around a common faith and morality. Gentiles did not need to become Jews to be included in the community, and Jews did not need to reject their heritage. All followers of Christ were expected to reject any other gods, reject sexual immorality, and live at peace with each other (1 Cor 8-10).

Historians say that the reason Christianity grew in influence in the Roman Empire was the love and morality of the believers. Julian the Apostate, a pagan emperor in the 360s (A.D.), lamented that he could not rally people around the old Roman gods and virtues the way Christians could mobilize their communities for good. A century earlier, Roman governors in a variety of provinces asked that they be allowed to delay persecution of Christians because the Christians were helping serve the victims of the plague. The incarnational apologetic of a changed life and virtues born of gratitude are powerful demonstrations to God’s grace. 

We are called to joyful hospitality, opening our communities to people of every background. We are also called to articulate clearly the holy love expected of followers of Jesus and to aspire to the obedience of faith. We will be met with opposition, declared intolerant, and often marginalized for our “backward views.” 

Yet, in the words of N.T. Wright, we must remind ourselves and the world around us that the ethics of Scripture are the “radical” ones and represent a departure from the norms of pagan (and 21st-century) culture.

No items found.


This story is from Common Good issue
Related Articles
All Articles >>>
good things come to
those in print

Scrolling works but it doesn't compare to that real-life, ink-and-paper feel.

No one said the conversations that matter should be easy. And no one said you have to enter them alone.